2 or 3?

Nicole Merdrignac ^club

Très belle capture. Nicole.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Nicole Merdrignac ^club

Très gentil Nicole, merci.

5 years ago.

Doug Shepherd ^club

Cracking capture Rosa!

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Doug Shepherd ^club

Thank you Doug.

5 years ago.

Jeff Farley

An excellent shot Rosa and many thanks for posting to Fur, Fin and Feather.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Jeff Farley

Thank you Jeff.

5 years ago.

neira-Dan ^club

belle prise

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to neira-Dan ^club

Merci Dan.

5 years ago.

HappySnapper

Good mono conversion Rosalyn.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to HappySnapper

Thank you Maurice.

5 years ago.

aNNa schramm ^club

2 + 1 = 3 :-))

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to aNNa schramm ^club

The third is a shadow of the second Anna ;-)

5 years ago.

volker_hmbg ^club

Perfect shot, Rosa!

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to volker_hmbg ^club

Thank you Volker.

5 years ago.

Ulrich John ^club

The right moment, Rosa ! Great in b/w !

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Ulrich John ^club

Thank you very much Ulrich.

5 years ago.

Keith Burton ^club

A cracking shot Rosa...........captured at the perfect moment. You must have lightning reflexes! I like both versions, but the B/W shot shows of the shadow on the wall much better!

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Keith Burton ^club

Thank you very much. I've got to keep an eye on them Keith....they are so clever, they might get the staples out of the feeders ;-))

5 years ago.

Nouchetdu38 ^club

Congratulations for your quick reflex !!!!!*****************

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Nouchetdu38 ^club

Thank you kindly Nouchet :)

5 years ago.

sea-herdorf ^club

Sehr schönes Schattenspiel, Rosa.
Superschuß!

Freundliche Grüße und einen schönen Abend
Erich

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to sea-herdorf ^club

Thank you very much Erich.
Have a great new week ahead.
Best wishes, Rosa.

5 years ago.

Andy Rodker ^club

Superb! Both!

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Andy Rodker ^club

Thanks Andy.

5 years ago.

Frans Schols ^club

Schitterende opname,Rosa en interessante pip.
Hartelijke groeten........Frans.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Frans Schols ^club

Thank you Frans.
Have a good new week.
Regards, Rosa.

5 years ago.

photosofghosts ^club

The first in shadow, but well detailed, the second between light and shadow, but well detailed again ,,,, and a magnificient shadow on the wall. A extraordinary sense of movement.
Great, great moment very well captured and composed, I particulary appreciated it !!
All the best
Fabio

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to photosofghosts ^club

Thank you for your very kind appraisal dear Fabio. The spring sunshine has returned, so I was delighted with the shadow....and the sun :) I could not make my mind up as to which I preferred but, like you. I feel the b&w version is stronger.

All the best, Rosa.

5 years ago.

photosofghosts ^club

P.S. the coloured one is beautiful, too but I prefer the one in b/w for its strong contrasts and the care of the edition of the birds in flight.
F.

5 years ago.

Christiane ♥.•*¨`*•✿

That is a fantastic capture, Rosalyn ! *******

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Christiane ♥.•*¨`*•✿

Thank you Christiane.

5 years ago.

Peter Castell ^club

The B&W is a great 'Hitchcock' style image but overall I prefer the colour version, I hope you have had a nice weekend Rosalyn

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Peter Castell ^club

Thank you Peter. I couldn't make up my mind, so it is good to get the feedback on both shots.
Another beautiful sunny day here. Have a good new week.

5 years ago.

gezginruh ^club

Great capture!! Just at perfect moment!
Excellent picture.Rosa!

Best wishes
Füsun

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to gezginruh ^club

Thank you Füsun. A lucky moment that we sometimes get :)

Best wishes, Rosa.

5 years ago.

Pam J ^club

LOVE THIS !

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Pam J ^club

Thank you Pam x

5 years ago.

Roger (Grisly) ^club

Perfect timing and they both work or me Rosa, but with a slight lean towards the colour version

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Roger (Grisly) ^club

Thank you for your kind feedback Roger.

5 years ago.

Jean

Outstanding capture. I love it.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Jean

Thank you very much Jean.

5 years ago.

Jaap van 't Veen ^club

Beautiful bird image; like the shadow on the wall.
The coloured version is a beauty.

5 years ago. Edited 5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Jaap van 't Veen ^club

Thank you very much Jaap.

5 years ago.

Marta Wojtkowska ^club

TBW & TDM!

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Marta Wojtkowska ^club

Thank you Marta.

5 years ago.

Marie-claire Gallet

Marvelous capture *********************

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Marie-claire Gallet

Merci beaucoup Marie-claire.

5 years ago.

Marie-claire Gallet

5 years ago.

Sarah O' ^club

Well done here Rosa, a fine composition...so to answer you "title question", Id say 2 ...but I have double vision of one of the birds:))) have a good week, regards, Sarah

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Sarah O' ^club

Thank you Sarah. Yes it is two, but the third is a shadow of the second....if that makes sense ;-))

5 years ago.

Sarah O' ^club has replied to Rosalyn Hilborne ^club

OH Rosa, I hope you know I was being silly there when saying I had "double vision" on that "3rd" bird! OF course the third is a shadow !! best wishes, Sarah

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Sarah O' ^club

Ha ha, no I didn't think you had double vision Sarah....All the best, Rosa.

5 years ago.

Amelia ^club

So much better in B&W, Rosa. And of course there are 3. ;-)
These birds remind of a time about 10 years ago when 2 young jackdaws came down our living room chimney and created havoc, spreading soot everywhere. We've since had proper pot protectors on all of our pots, even only3 chimneys are working.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Amelia ^club

Gosh, those are big birds to get down your chimney!! I used to notice them on the chimney of the house opposite building their nest! They too have now installed pot protectors!

5 years ago.

Peter_Private_Box ^club

Hi Rosa,

This is a wonderful picture, and very cleverly done. I like it very much!!
Now to answer the riddle...

Let A = B
(A * B) = (A * A)
(A * B) - (B*B) = (A*A) - (B*B)
(A -B) * B = (A - B) * (A + B)
B = (A + B)
Let A = 1 => 1 = 1 + 1 ie 1 = 2
Since 1 = 2 => 1 + 1 = 2 + 1 => 2 =3
So, you have the same number regardless of how you classify them!!

Best Wishes
Peter

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Peter_Private_Box ^club

Hi Peter,

I think I will take your word for it ;-))
I am pleased you like the picture, thank you.

Best wishes, Rosa.

5 years ago.

Joe, Son of the Rock ^club

It would be nice if it were three, Rosa, as that would remind me of a traditional Scottish song. Cheers, Joe

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Joe, Son of the Rock ^club

If only I knew the tune, I would sing it Joe. LOL! I might need a translation though!
Cheers, Rosa.

5 years ago.

John Goodwin

Ooops missed this gem... lovely play with light, and shadow... well done well spotted.

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to John Goodwin

That's OK John, but thanks for finding it and for your nice comment.

5 years ago.

Beatrice Degan(MARS)

So belated comment but I was off for about a fortnight !
Deeply impressed by this so clever capture turned into a very intense and marvellous art work!
The coloured one is a beauty but I Love more this B&W one. I mean I feel a much deeper emotional impact.
Ciao Rosa !

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Beatrice Degan(MARS)

Thank you for much for your very kind and measured comments Bea.
I think you are right about the b&w version, and I am very pleased you like it.

Best wishes, Rosa.

5 years ago.

Roger (Grisly) ^club

Superb light and shadow Rosa, you must be quick on the trigger I would have missed them.

Thank you for posting in the group
www.ipernity.com/group/magicalsunlight

5 years ago.

Ste

Fantastic capture Rosa ...well done indeed

Best wishes ... Steve

5 years ago.

Rosalyn Hilborne ^club has replied to Ste

Thank you so much Steve.

Best regards, Rosa.

5 years ago.

©UdoSm ^club

Excellent...

21 months ago.

Thank you Udo.

21 months ago.

		Page color
		Comments Panel
		Screen Margins
▼▲
		Widescreen

← Among Rosalyn Hilborne's photos

See also...

My Garden Pictures. Flowers, Birds & Insects. My Garden Pictures. Flowers, Birds & Insects.

Pictures for Pam Pictures for Pam

" A Yin & Yang group - Light & Shadow - Licht & Schatten - Lumière & Ombre " " A Yin & Yang group - Light & Shadow - Licht & Schatten - Lumière & Ombre "

Drei Dinge - three things - tre cose - trois choses Drei Dinge - three things - tre cose - trois choses

Pic-in-Pic - Welcome to the group... Pic-in-Pic - Welcome to the group...

Les yeux, miroirs de l'âme Les yeux, miroirs de l'âme

Le groupe noir et blanc Le groupe noir et blanc

All animals of creation -PHOTOS and DIGITAL ART All animals of creation -PHOTOS and DIGITAL ART

Pictures friends - Amis Photos - Bilder Freunde Pictures friends - Amis Photos - Bilder Freunde

The Decisive Moment The Decisive Moment

'The Black & White' 'The Black & White'

black and white photography black and white photography

Magical sunlight Magical sunlight

Cucho B&W Cucho B&W

Your Shock Photos Your Shock Photos

De lumière et d'ombres - light and shadows De lumière et d'ombres - light and shadows

nos amis à plumes...... nos amis à plumes......

Mes Préférences à Moi Mes Préférences à Moi

Coup de coeur !!! Coup de coeur !!!

Birds of a feather Birds of a feather

❖ Ipernity Photo Gallery ❖ ❖ Ipernity Photo Gallery ❖

Authorizations, license

2 or 3?

Ξ	Frame Options
3 - +