Earl-Jean (Reavis) of the Cookies was first to record "I'm Into Something Good" (Goffin - King) in 1964. The single peaked at number thirty-eight on Billboard.

Later that same year Herman's Hermits (Peter Noone, Derek Leckenby, Barry Whitwarn, Karl Green and Keith Hopwood) 1964 debut single was this cover of "I'm Into Something Good" as produced by Mickie Most. The tune reached number thirteen and was the start of an envious career.