Group: HFF - HAPPY FENCE FRIDAY
Open Discussion for all in the group.
![]() |
By
Steve Paxton
club
|
We the Administrators/Moderators of the group would like to open a means of communication with all the members. The topic is what would you like it to be eg what you would like to see/ how the group is run or could be run/how can we improve/do you want to see changes for better or not ...open to you...
This is an open letter to us all, Your thoughts as a group. If some thing is raised here it will be taken to another Discussion group if we cant sort it out in a few comments here as another thread.
Remember you now have four people who volunteered to look after the group and learn for the groups benefit. we want all to do the best for the group to keep going forward.
This is an open letter to us all, Your thoughts as a group. If some thing is raised here it will be taken to another Discussion group if we cant sort it out in a few comments here as another thread.
Remember you now have four people who volunteered to look after the group and learn for the groups benefit. we want all to do the best for the group to keep going forward.
The topic of this discussion has been edited by Steve Paxton 8 months ago.
You must be a member of this group to reply to this topic. (Join?)
Jump to top
RSS feed- Latest comments - Subscribe to the comment feed for this topic
- ipernity © 2007-2025
- Help & Contact
|
Club news
|
About ipernity
|
History |
ipernity Club & Prices |
Guide of good conduct
Donate | Group guidelines | Privacy policy | Terms of use | Statutes | In memoria -
Facebook
X
Boarischa Krautmo club has replied to Karl Hartwig Schütz clubWith no rules ;-))))))
Es kann doch jeder für sich soviel Zaunfotos hochladen wie er möchte ...
ABER ES MUSS JA NICHT IN DIE HFF-GRUPPE SEIN
aNNa schramm club has addedHeidiho club has replied to aNNa schramm clubSimple Regel, die leicht zu merken und einzuhalten ist.
.. die (wenn ich es richtig sehe) von Jens losgetretene "Bürokratie-Debatte" ist m.E. überhaupt erst dadurch entstanden, daß Einige (er auch !) meinen, massenhaft Zaun-Fotos in die Gruppe schaufeln zu müssen. Dass war NIE Sinn dieser Gruppe.
Ingo Krehl club has replied to aNNa schramm clubIngo Krehl club has replied to Heidiho clubI think if a divider could be added to separate the weeks it would be useful
Karen's Place club has replied to Peter Castell clubWarum sollte das hier anders sein ........ als im wahren Leben? {;o)
Ingo Krehl club has replied to Ur@nos clubContext, description and relevance best left to the author in most cases I reckon.
ps maybe a note somewhere explaining that the photo does not need to have been taken nor posted to Ipernity on a Friday though. Simply this group.
Diana Australis club has replied to Herb Riddle clubThis group worked very well for years without admin, without rules, without discussions - and became one of ipernity's most successful groups. Perhaps for these three reasons....
So I cannot see any need to change a succesful group. Moderation will take time an manpower, moderation will disencourage some members - and till now there wasn't ever any need for moderation.
I can't see any need for changes at all.
Boarischa Krautmo club has addedI really appreciate that there is this discussion giving members the chance to explain their arguments and to try to convince others.
Tanja - Loughcrew club has replied to Boarischa Krautmo clubErhard Bernstein club has replied to Boarischa Krautmo clubJaap van 't Veen club has replied to Tanja - Loughcrew clubErhard Bernstein club has replied to Tanja - Loughcrew clubKaren's Place club has replied to Tanja - Loughcrew clubKarl Hartwig Schütz club has replied to Karen's Place clubBut as people have then very likely discovered, the majority does not read the group rules and discussions anyway. So, I guess people have either just given up and left the group(s), or started to ignore the whole situation and keep on dumping images everywhere they can and want to.
The way how former owner of this web site (Ipernity S.A.) arranged the algorithms for groups and group guidelines were pretty well thought, except the situation when the group administration goes to some absent user account. In the ideal situation there would always be some existing group administrator to contact. And if nothing else, then that administrator could at least say:
"Sorry, as a group administrator I say this is how it should be. You are free to choose whether to let things go, or leave the group."
One argument and rhetoric really then is to say it should not matter if groups go "wild", with no administration at all. It is then of course one option. Most of the groups here at ipernity has become as such. They are nothing else but shared folders to dump as many images as people like to. Not much different than to view through some search results or keywords.
For example one could just as well run this search every Friday:
www.ipernity.com/search/photo?opt=1&q=happy+fence+friday&w=0&t=0&lic=&s=2
And then go through those search results.
So, how about choosing someone else to administrate this group? Someone who really does not care about limitations. Or even make it as a rule that everyone are supposed to submit at least 10 contributions every Friday.
And that was supposed to be taken as sarcasm. Meaning, that we can at least try to find some solution that most of the group members agree on. Set at least a limit of 10 images per week if nothing else, to avoid someone taking the "anarchy" to another extreme and submit 100 contributions at once.
The problem of course is as said, that people have used to ignore group rules and discussions unless they are forced to realize that something is going on. So, we may also have to admit this discussion here really is a waste of time. Majority of group members may not even know there is something going on.
I am administrating several groups myself, and I must say it is not very nice to find out someone has uploaded a lot of images at once. It is then most unpleasant to remove them and try to explain it to that person.
And the final point of this rant of mine is to say, that at least when we hopefully get enough money to reprogram ipernity, we then should reconsider the whole group thing. It is most certainly not easy to please everyone. Or let's acknowledge it, it is impossible to please everyone. But we can at least try to.
Heidiho club has replied to Sami Serola (inactiv… clubIngo Krehl club has replied to Sami Serola (inactiv… clubAnnemarie club has replied to Sami Serola (inactiv… clubBergfex club has replied to Annemarie clubIt's such a pity that Sami has retired.
Ich verstehe, dass ein Admin Regeln eingehalten haben möchte und ich zieh den Hut vor allen,
die diesen Job machen aber hier läuft was total falsch! Zusammenhalt bedeutet Toleranz und ein Lächeln...ich möchte Meines nicht verlieren...Bitte!!!!!
bonsai59 club has replied to Tanja - Loughcrew clubAnnemarie club has replied to Tanja - Loughcrew clubKarl Hartwig Schütz club has replied to Annemarie clubWenn nun Jens beispielsweise 3 Fotos hochlädt, so erlauben das die bisherigen Regeln. Und - Jens hat auch schon früher öfter 3 Fotos hochgeladen - keinen hat es gestört, warum also jetzt dieses Theater ? Wir wollen doch einfach hier nur unseren Spaß haben. Manchmal wird auch durch Diskussionen einfach zuviel zerredet - schade ...
Jaap van 't Veen club has replied to Percy Schramm clubTanja - Loughcrew club has replied to Percy Schramm clubbonsai59 club has replied to Percy Schramm clubBoarischa Krautmo club has replied to Percy Schramm clubErhard Bernstein club has replied to Percy Schramm clubUli F. club has replied to Percy Schramm clubKarl Hartwig Schütz club has replied to Uli F. clubXata club has replied to Percy Schramm clubNow I am not the only admin here, Erika who was there before I was has to agree on that.
www.ipernity.com/group/311821/discuss/189404
Made the point perfectly clear to us all. so I recommend we close that topic as "sorted" before it get into the uncivil thoughts. It looks like the number three is a point we can be all "happy with". I know, most will sort out our best , put in one shot. we have the right to comment or not on any photo with out putting some one in a bad light by not commenting.
I think that there is more than can be talked about than just the number of photos but this is how we learn. I believe also the topic of Thursday night entries is also a non starter as I believe it reasonable as well I know if I add a photo just before I go to bed Thursday night is not even close to Friday as far as Europe is concerned. We are a world of different time zones but I do think that we can draw the line at posting on the early part of the week. this is my thought and that also ties up well with what has already been discussed on the other thread as well.
I believe this is also a discussion that has been well thrashed out.
I do under stand Sami concerns as we are only seeing the same voices on the threads it may be we need to make the rest aware of the tread and how they should have there say here as well.
I would like to point out we are not making rules just trying to understand the wishes of the group that's why the discussion. If the points below make it as guide lines for the group we all agreed on them as how we can go forward.
1/ number of photos 3 for those that wish a week . Closed
2/ time to add photos early as possible to "your" Friday in your time zone. Closed
So the tread is still open on what we all would like to talk about eg .........
FarbFormFreude club has replied to Steve Paxton clubHerb Riddle club has replied to Steve Paxton clubto do this the chosen photo we need to get the Photographers permission to use the photo to add it to the banner much like mine. hope the idea is a good one.
Herb Riddle club has replied to Steve Paxton clubTanja - Loughcrew club has replied to Steve Paxton clubJaap van 't Veen club has replied to Steve Paxton clubHerb Riddle club has replied to Jaap van 't Veen clubSami Serola (inactiv… club has replied to Steve Paxton clubI also suggest considering Creative Commons license. With proper attribution selected one gives only permission to republish, and it always requires that the author of original work becomes mentioned.
For example choose Creative Commons "Attribution + non Commercial + no derivative":
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
Steve D has replied to Steve Paxton clubnot every week I post HFF picas, but I enjoy yours......so lets go on:)
Thanks to the 4 for the efforts!
What pleases or even not, is nevertheless very individual I keep it there with Immanuel Kant
Taste is not a matter for dispute
Jaap van 't Veen club has replied to Keith Burton clubPhil club has replied to Keith Burton clubAn die Administratoren
Ich darf zwar drei Bilder pro Woche in die Gruppe einstellen aber die Software lässt mich nur alle 168 Stunden drei Bilder einstellen. Letzte Woche habe ich sie 9.00 Uhr eingestellt, heute habe ich sie erst 10.30 Uhr eingestellt, da ich kurz nach neun keine Zeit hatte. Das heißt, dass ich sie in der nächsten Woche erst nach 10.30 einstellen kann. Vermutlich werde ich sie in einem halben Jahr dann erst am Samstag einstellen können und niemand sieht sie mehr. Es wäre gut das zu ändern, so das ich sie am Freitag zu beliebiger Zeit in die Gruppe einstellen könnte.
Freundliche Grüße Jens
--- Translated by Google ---
To the Administrators
Although I am allowed to add three pictures per week to the group, the software only allows me to set three pictures every 168 hours. Last week I set them at 9 o'clock, today I did not set them until 10.30 o'clock, since I am short after nine had no time. That means I will not be able to hire them until 10.30 next week. Probably I will be able to hire them in half a year on Saturday and no one will see them anymore. It would be good to change that, so I'll get them on Friday could put any time in the group. Best regards Jens.
the limit has been set as three photo a week I can not change the soft ware you may have to go to the Ipernity board. I post one photo and never have a problem...
Steve
Ich veröffentliche immer nur ein Foto, weil ich mir dann vorher mehr Gedanken über dieses Foto mache. Das heißt, ich muss eine Entscheidung fällen, ob dieses Foto auch wirklich einem bestimmten Thema entspricht. Hier sind es: "Zäune".
Ich überlege mir dann:
- Ist mein Zaun nur zufällig auf dem Foto?
- Habe ich den Zaun bewusst fotografiert, weil er z. B. einen Rahmen bildet oder den Blick lenkt, das Motiv strukturiert usw. ?
- Ist er zentrales Element des Fotos, z. B. Detailaufnahme.
Diesen Anspruch stelle ich mir. Ob ich ihn erfülle? Das weiß ich nicht.
Aber Fotos von Türen, Tore usw. gehören für mich definitiv nicht zum Thema dieser Gruppe. Da kommt dann wohl eher der olympische Gedanke zum Tragen: Hier sein und mitmachen ist alles. Das fördert zwar dann den Zusammenhalt von Gruppenmitgliedern, aber mein Lehrer hätte früher gesagt: Ein toller Beitrag, aber leider das Thema verfehlt. :-))
In dieser Gruppe würde ich mir aber wünschen, dass bei den Fotos, die veröffentlicht werden, mehr Augenmerk auf das zentrale Element Zaun gelegt wird. Manchmal muss ich ihn ziemlich suchen. ;-)
HFF
Thorsten
Ingo Krehl club has replied to ThorstenI have to rely on the translation and I hope that its is not lost "In translation".
You can see by the first part of this conversation the heated remarks that have been made. I also only post one photo per week so could not see what the problem is but the conversation got quite heated.
This was a topic I also wanted to bring up but after the "number of photos" saga I thought best left alone. to that aim I will defer to the group as well on this point I do think its a valid point some of the fences you just cant see them at all.
what is a "FENCE" gate ,stone wall or the very liberal idea the group has. like your teacher said
A great contribution, but unfortunately missed the point. :-))
up to the group but a worthy point.
"Happy Friday FENCE" but not "Happy Friday Flowerpower".
Btw. "Happy Friday Flowerpower" would be a nice new group ;-)
@ Quantity
My wish: one photo per week. More photos can be shown in the form of PiPs. But that is not so important for me.
HFF @ everyone!
Ingo Krehl club has replied to Thorstenwww.ipernity.com/group/311821/discuss/192612
Steve
Xata club has replied to Steve Paxton clubma faute est certainement parce que j'ai négligé de poster la photo le vendredi,
dommage les copains, c'était sympa d'être avec vous......
vos administrateurs sont pires qu'inquisition catholique, ...... c'est l'inquisition cathodique ou électronique et ce n'est pas drôle.........
merci encore........
Xata club has replied to DamirDamir, je ne connais personne qui vous ait retiré du groupe et je vois que vous faites toujours partie de HFF. J'essaie d'aller sur la traduction ici, donc si les choses ne sont pas tout à fait correctes, vous comprendrez peut-être pourquoi. Nous avons pris l'initiative de fermer le groupe du samedi au mercredi, car le groupe est entièrement consacré au vendredi, mais nous l'avons ouvert jeudi - dimanche pour que toutes les contributions du monde entier s'affichent dans leurs fuseaux horaires. C'est plus une tentative de remettre de l'ordre qu'une inquisition, j'ai hâte de voir votre photo dans les temps, comme tout le monde.
Xata club has replied to Steve Paxton clubto all the photographers look forward to a new years 2020 all the very best to every body.
aNNa schramm club
Eigentlich ist es ja kein Zaun sondern eine Brücke mit Geländer !!
--- Translated by DeepL ---
Actually it is not a fence but a bridge with railings !
31 hours ago.
aNNa schramm
aNNa schramm club
Wieso und warum werden jetzt bereit schon am Donnerstag Bilder in die Gruppe eingestellt ?????????????
--- Translated by DeepL ---
Why and why are pictures already being uploaded to the group on Thursday ????????????????????????????????
31 hours ago.
please reed a very small set of rules.
Nice fence Photos on Friday !
1. 3 photos a week.
2. Post late Thursday night (your Time Zone) or Friday. NOT SATURDAY to WEDNESDAY
3. This a family friendly group no nudity.
this is our group Rules late night Thursday is late night Thursday In "Your time zone" not just Europe's we are a world wide group over many time zones.
what is a fence there is no hard and fast rule on that one yet....
Steve Paxton club has replied to aNNa schramm clubI would hate to loose any of our photographers but to loose them and not know is even worse. I know that my own 92 year old father in NZ is healthy but the virus has yet to reach them but for sure it will in time.
from the administrators of the group please take care and look after your selves its not, its not going to happen is only "when". the world is about to change in a way we just not comfortable with.
all sport played with no spectators .... is that really sport, that's the start of sport here from today.
To all our members please take care and follow advice.
Tanja - Loughcrew club has replied to Steve Paxton clubWichtiger ist mir, dass auf dem Foto der Zaun das bildbestimmende Motiv ist!
Nicht ein schönes Foto wo irgendwo ein Zaun mit drauf ist – wir sind eine Foto-Gemeinschaft.
Was alles ein gültiger „Zaun“ ist würde ich so definieren:
Es ist eine körperliche Abtrennung die Flächen von einander trennt, keine Trennlinie auf der Straße.
Zu den Begriff „Zäune“ würde ich weit auslegen. Also auch Geländer, Tore, Türen aber keine Tore und Türen von Gebäuden. Die Größe des „Zaun“ von der Chinesischen Mauer bis zu kleinen Zäunen an Wegen oder Beet-Umrandungen.
Eine gute Definition halte ich für jede Gruppe wichtig. Sie gibt den Mitglieder eine Orientierung und den Admins eine Grundlage für Entscheidungen.
Im Zweifel sollte sollte die Vielfalt der „Zäune“ wichtiger als die Definition sein.
Erika+Manfred club has replied to Ingo Krehl clubGudrun club has replied to Ingo Krehl clubwww.ipernity.com/group/311821/discuss/189404
There are good reasons why "creative freedom" on the choice of subject should not be limited. There are also good reasons why more than one contribution per week was set. But if you indeed fill the quota of 16 contributions per month allowed, then consider posting for example only 10 per month. If you stubbornly try to cling on some of your personal right of being able to post exactly three contributions every week, then this is not the right group for you.
17 months ago It was also more or less agreed who were willing to take over this group. Volunteers were asked to take over, and they were chosen. And they are now whom you should respect.
@ All - Please respect the group administration. Constructive feedback is fine. But if the group is not what you like, then find a better one, or start a group of your own.
And remember the 'Guide of good conduct': www.ipernity.com/about/guidelines
But I still wish myself the greatest possible artistic freedom. I don't care if the fence is the dominant element of the picture or just an accessory. Even a snail fence would make me smile as a creative contribution! (Such a thing may not look like a fence, but it is called that.) So give it to me. Because in the title of this group is the word 'Happy'. Thus one may also laugh about artistically individual contributions. Or shouldn't we?
1) I totally agree on what Bernhard says. So, don't worry, be happy...
2) If some people seem to get worried that people are leaving the group for some reason, no need to worry either. Maybe it then makes someone else interested to join. Especially this time of the year on the northern hemisphere is less active than usually. Even if many of us are pensioners, people have still used to have a summer vacation, and they are therefore having a vacation also from internet.
3) Bear in mind that sometimes quality is better than quantity. So, one contribution per week can be better than many. Even if the group allows more, it does not mean one should upload many. More images there are posted per a group member every Friday, more images there are to look through for others. And that can be exhausting. So, instead I suggest using those picture in picture (PiP) notes for extra. Or put the other images into image caption. If your account does not allow you post PiPs or images on notes, then add them as URL links onto comments. Then those who do like to see more from some member, can have that option. And those who do wish to browse through all contributions by all members, can have that option.
kann es sein, das genau 7 x 24 Stunden vergehen müssen, damit man wieder in die Gruppe kommt?
or Friday (Your time zone). NOT SATURDAY to THURSDAY
PLEASE NOTE: Photos added after the weekly "STOP" sign and those posted out of time on THURSDAY NIGHT "YOUR LOCAL TIME" will simply be removed.
We as a group volunteered 3 years ago before the group was closed as it had no administrator. We would like to offer some one else the chance to run this group. We would like to see some names of those who would like the chance to make a difference.
look forward to hearing from the group.
Xata clubGestern ein Bild in die Gruppe eingestellt und stelle fest, gnadenlos gelöscht (Wilfrieds Erben?).
OK, Blick in die Regeln, Hochladen am Donnerstag erst nach 23.30 Uhr. Hmmm, das ist mir zu spät ihr Lieben, Vorschlag 20 Uhr. Viele sind berufstätig, ich stehe um 4.30 Uhr auf, heute eine Ausnahme. Dann erst nach Feierabend die Möglichkeit, aber man hat noch andere Sachen zu tun.
Das sollte hier Spaß sein, nicht so engstirnig und bierernst. Man will doch nur seine Kollegen grüßen, mir geht es nicht um die Chancengleichheit.
Aber gut, das entscheiden die Admins.
Gruß Uwe
Steve Paxton club has replied to uwschu clubuwschu club has replied to Steve Paxton clubHerb Riddle club has replied to uwschu clubThe rules are clearly stated on the 'About this Group' panel. Maybe they will change some day but until that happens we all try to abide with them no matter our personal circumstances.
uwschu club has replied to Herb Riddle clubDie Bitte geht nur darum, vielleicht ein wenig die Zeit nach vorn zu lockern.
Ansonsten werde ich mich an die Regeln halten oder eben keins einstellen. Wie Bernhard es formulierte, das Wort HAPPY sollte Sinnbild dieser Gruppe sein.
Gruß Uwe