[EN] Comments improvements

an den deutschen Übersetzungen muss aber noch gefeilt werden ...

Test.

Uff, thanks for this!!

BUG: If I click "(see the discussion)" twice, same discussion appears once more (every click leads to the same: once more and more again)

Still comments missing! eg. www.ipernity.com/doc/anke/11526283?lc=1#comments
I can't see 47 comments!!

Oh oh! Sorry if you're encountering those problems. We'll fix them Thursday (Wednesday the 1s t of May is off in France).

Nearly perfect. If I reply, the reply is below the comment i replied to. If I reload the page, the reply is not below the entry I replied to any longer...

After clicking "reply", we had two options to display the editing box:
-either directly under the "reply" link
-or under the last reply which needs sometimes to scroll down

We took the first option which is more user friendly.

Of course, once refreshed, the page shows replies sortered by posted date.

We consider it's not a problem because there is no particular need to refresh the page after posting a comment.

I'll try again, I was not able to add a comment, it just went crazy trying to load without succes.

Seems there was a fast rollback, due to a new bug...

The problem has just been mentioned to me in a message from a friend. Like me she is not able to add a comment to the Guestbook

John.

Oh oh! Sorry if you're encountering some problems. We'll fix them Thursday (Wednesday the 1st of May is off in France).

Regarding the Guestbook.
I believe the problem has arrissen because we now have the most recent at the top, but still use the bottom for new comments.

John.

Enjoy you day off.

Have a nice holiday! But here is really something broken, check this on thursday. If I click on "All ( )" I will see only my comments. Not all. And if I reply, it´s first below that comment I post a reply. After reload not. And: There is a need to relaod the page. Then, wenn I want to check if there is something new after some time. Yea? Please: Check your code before integrating, especially, when working continous. Sorry.

As we previously said, what you describe is not a bug but a choice of design (there are pros and cons in the 2 options we've mentionned above). But maybe our choice was not the good one. Let's wait a couple of days. Anyway, if you are on "latest comments" view, refreshing your page will always put the latest comments and replied at the bottom.

Concerning bugs, be sure we double check before putting online. But there are sometimes slice differences between our development platform and the real one which also causes bugs. Be sure we'll fix them tomorrow.

Ok, then it´s a feature, not a bug! For my perspective this feature is unhandy. I saw not the "see the discussion"-link. If I click on it I see below the discussion, nice!. But this results in seeing the my reply sorted in the timeline by date/time, the original post, then my again my reply. I see now your intention to have always a date sorted timeline with the newest comment at the end; combined with discussion threads the current solution is not optimal, for my point of view, because you do not have the feeling to open a folded thread (Or to say it in another way: I was confused, because I never saw a discussion thread behavior like this before).

Proposal: Show all beginning posts sorted by date/time, below each starting post the newest reply with a expansion twisty, which flaps out all replies of this specific starting post. In your condensed start view show all new posts and posts with replies sorted by the date/time of reply. If clicking on All: Just show all, if you want with flapped in threads, but latest reply below the starting thread entry...