6 favorites     14 comments    328 visits

1/320 f/11.0 19.8 mm ISO 100

SONY DSC-RX100M2

EXIF - See more details

See also...

Flickr Refugees Flickr Refugees


Downtown Toronto Downtown Toronto


Toronto Toronto


See more...

Keywords

canada
toronto
ontario
ocad
Sharp centre for design


Authorizations, license

Visible by: Everyone
All rights reserved

328 visits


Sharp Centre for Design

Sharp Centre for Design
The shoebox supported by knitting needles is the Sharp Centre for Design (Alsop Architects, 2004) at OCAD University in Toronto. OCAD was formerly the Ontario College of Art and Design, and originally the Ontario School of Art.

Although the building has won important awards (the first Royal Institute of British Architects Worldwide Award, the award of excellence in the "Building in Context" category at the Toronto Architecture and Urban Design Awards, most outstanding technical project overall in the 2005 Canadian Consulting Engineering Awards), it always finishes near the top in an annual survey of people's opinions of the ugliest buildings in Toronto, and features in a few videos on YouTube about the ugliest buildings in the world.

Off to the left is part of Frank Gehry's extension of the Art Gallery of Ontario. Inside the extension is a very effective art gallery, but as someone said to me about the outside, "It's no Bilbao" I'm not blaming Gehry -- Toronto is where great architects come to have their ideas thwarted by their committees. The one architect they couldn't defeat was Mies, who, of course, was known for his ability to drink any site foreman under the table, an ability he used to get things done his way.

, tiabunna, Gisela Plewe, Berny and 2 other people have particularly liked this photo


14 comments - The latest ones
 rdhinmn
rdhinmn club
You're own opinion of the architecture does come through. The buildings are suitably enmeshed in power lines, tram lines, whatever, and lorded over by an inquisitive crane.

Are you sure the comment about the Gehry mentioned Barcelona, not Bilbao?
6 years ago.
 John FitzGerald
John FitzGerald club
You're right, Bob. It's Bilbao. I'll fix it. Thanks. What really bothers me about this building is its impracticality.
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has added
Well, I finally fixed it. Had it as "Bilboa" for a while.
6 years ago.
 Keith Burton
Keith Burton club
It doesn't do much for me I'm afraid - except that I like the way the box looks pixelated.
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Keith Burton club
There's something for everyone in that building, Keith.
6 years ago.
 Sarah P.
Sarah P. club
"Shoebox supported by knitting needles" -- well put, and well photographed. Kudos as always to Bob for his insightful and creative comments ("suitably enmeshed in power lines, tram lines, whatever, and lorded over by an inquisitive crane."
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Sarah P. club
The mesh is part of Toronto's retro charm, Sarah -- lots of overhead wires, streetcars that run in the streets instead of a right-of-way, Liberal stronghold.

I agree about Bob's comments, of course. This building, by the way, is not the one I consider the ugliest in Toronto. This one is:
media.gettyimages.com/photos/talotta-1-exrerior-shots-of-colborne-lodge-in-high-park-anshei-minsk-picture-id165455437

Despite the link claiming that it's Colborne Lodge, it's actually Graduate House at the University of Toronto. The photograph doesn't capture its look of having been burnt out in a fire.

À chacun son goût, of course.
6 years ago. Edited 6 years ago.
 Jean
Jean
Love your description of it. It will look better when sea levels rise by a few metres.
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Jean
Hmm. This is very close to the lake, Jean. Actually, downtown Toronto is on the bed of a glacial lake that formed during the last Ice Age. Luckily I live on the hill which starts at the old shoreline.
6 years ago.
Sarah P. club has replied to Jean
LOL! :-D
6 years ago.
 Gisela Plewe
Gisela Plewe club
I wish to come there!
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Gisela Plewe club
We're ready for tourists, Gisela. I always thing that Toronto is a great place to live but I wouldn't want to visit there, but people from elsewhere keep coming.
6 years ago.
 tiabunna
tiabunna club
I rather like the added charm of the crane, John. Strange, isn't it, how architectural awards often go to buildings that either are judged ugly by the general community, or impractical by the occupants.
6 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to tiabunna club
Thanks, George. I wouldn't have taken the shot without the crane; it's bright and its strong vertical adds some order to the mix of wires and perspectives, That may be true of all awards, I'm afraid.

I'm not a fan of Alain de Botton, but I do like his idea that people put up buildings that help calm their fears. Toronto's building-erecting classes seem terrified of not being hip, so they approve unusual buildings to prove how hip they are. Well, more often they erect buildings in a style someone said was hip somewhere else. Toronto was the last place to put up buildings in Mies' Seagram Building style, but they put up five on the same site. Hip or what, eh?
6 years ago.

Sign-in to write a comment.