Last weekend, I became the target of photography haters. But before you dismiss my claim, consider my story, because I have not made myself guilty of insulting anyone:
I was in a crowded square in downtown Munich, Germany (on the "Münchener Freiheit"), watching old men playing a game of chess using huge wooden chess men - a very concentrated, peaceful scene. I shot a number of portraits of an old man in his seventies with a highly interesting face and then walked away. It was warm, the light was perfect and everybody was relaxed and calm.
Several minutes later, I suddenly found myself surrounded by four or five men and women in their late twenties or early thirties. Obviously Germans, so this was not a religion-based problem. At first, the scene looked somewhat like a harmless prank because they all were using water guns to make me wet from all sides, including my sensitive photography gear.
But then, they pulled in on me and started insulting me because I had been taking photographs. Mind you, the people who harassed me were completely unknown to me, and I couldn't even find them in the background of any of the pictures I shot. It seems they were not afraid of having been photographed because none of them asked to see my pictures and have theirs deleted in case they would have been on one of them - a fairly normal occurrence these days in Germany which I would have reacted to by deleting pictures as requested without further discussion.
Instead, they came closer and closer, and the scene became increasingly menacing. What would you do if you would see a situation developing in which you're going to be attacked by a group of young, apparently strong and healthy people, whereas you aren't a very sportsy type and you are in your late fifties? Anyway, the scene became very loud, with three or four of them yelling at me, and myself thinking about what to do next in order to not get beaten up on the spot (Quite remarkable - we were on a square with about two hundred witnesses who sat at the tables of a nearby street cafe. They all watched, but nobody interfered).
I had to do something. Immediately. And I did: Instead of staying on the defensive, I brusquely started an attack on one of the men surrounding me, threatening to hit him with my camera (I had a very solid 80-200 f 2.8 lens attached). I was lucky. I scared the entire gang away without hurting anyone.
I was glad the situation was resolved in a good way, but I'm left with an uneasy feeling, not understanding the reason of the attack. And this was not the only attack i had experienced. Two years ago, I had also been in a crowded place in Munich, trying to test my then brand-new (and huge, highly conspicuous) wideangle zoom lens. I got harrassed by someone immediately after having taken my camera out of my bag, before I had even started taking any pictures at all.
It seems the general 9/11 hysteria with imposed, ridiculous rules on photography is gradually seeping into the subconscious of all those nutheads in our cities....
Have you experienced similar things? What do you feel about this? How would you react, or how did you react when something similar would/has happen(ed) to you?
tschnitzlein has replied to wdjI tell you, this was one scary experience. Most of all because it happened before the eyes of hundreds of impassive onlookers. The perfect fabric of scary movies or nightmares.
--
Seen in my account recent activity (?)
I think the truth is these "kids" were being bullies and in many other instances I have heard about this is the case, whether it is anti social youth or bullshit private security or police or other figures of state authority we live in a world that is continuing to be more paranoid, more socially conservative and demanding of conformity. Of course history has a funny way of changing directions so we shall see, but for now we still live in the world of Bush and his ilk no matter the country of origin.
I read this British information technology magazine "The Register" and it seems that they are even further along in the world of decreasing personal freedoms.
tschnitzlein has replied to LarryosanI'm working on the PP for one of the portraits. Anyway - the picture won't provide a clue as to why the incident occurred...
> I think you were a target of opportunity.
This may very well be the case. However, I'm sure that there's a connection: Starting with 9/11, Germany saw a crunch on image copyright and Internet publication legislation that is quite remarkable. It seems photographers have been put under some pre-emptive suspicion, almost as if we would snatch peoples' souls by portraying them. The dispute is fought out with an almost religious fervor...
> I read this British information technology magazine "The Register" and it seems that they are even further along in the world of decreasing personal freedoms.
You may be right. Germany has been lucky enough that it hasn't yet seen any successful terrorist attack like the subway bombing in London or the Atocha bomb attack in Madrid. I don't even dare to think what would happen over here if there would be a successful attack in Germany... We have lots of politicians who would just love to use the occasion to implement their own theories on public safety ...
tschnitzlein has replied to TomusanWell, I don't know, Munich these days isn't exactly known for its Nazis - it's the only major city in Bavaria that has had a stable social democratic municipality for decades. And it generally is a place one can feel safe from political violence. That's what makes the incident so unsettling and hard to understand.
> Sad that everyone around you looked away.
Hm - isn't that the normal way in any major, anonymous city (Munich is Germany's third-largest city with a downtown population of 1.5 million - just within city limits)?
tschnitzlein has replied to Jerry LeeIt takes a lot of self-detachedness to get that. And besides, I wouldn't get the point of the performance.
--
Seen in my account recent activity (?)
I know this is completely unrelated to the people stopping you and I still wonder how it was a mixed male-female group. Maybe it was one of those spontaneous street theaters? It all seems a bit silly all... the water pistols, the yelling and how they finally ran away but I wasn't there...
I'm with Don and Jerry. You were never in danger if you 'scared the entire gang away' with a single move. A group looking for a fight expects and welcomes resistance. An aggressive move from its prey is just a signal to start the brawl.
I'd feel surprised and intimidated, too, as you did. But feelings aside--what do you know?
You know the 'gang' consisted of men and women, you know 'hundreds of people' could see, and you know the light was good (you were using it for your photos, yes?). You also know the 'gang' ran away at the precise instant it would have to if it wanted to avoid anyone being seriously hurt.
Sounds like street theatre. And very clever street theatre at that. As a street photographer yourself you should appreciate it. The casting was perfect.
The point of the scene?
The art they make, using you, is like the art you make, using others. The artist approaches a stranger in a public spot and starts using that person as raw material for art--without ever seeking that person for permission or explaining what is going on.
Consider some of the interesting parallels. Your rules of etiquette, you say, are to assume everyone around you is fair game for photography until an individual protests. The 'gang' treated you as fair game for theatre until you protested.
You tell us you are in your fifties and thus older than the people who surprised you. You saw the age difference as limiting your ability to assert yourself. But you also tell us that, only a moment earlier, you made portraits as you pleased of 'an old man in his seventies.'
Food for thought.
tschnitzlein has replied to Alton--
Seen in my account recent activity (?)
Lars Trebing has replied to tschnitzleintschnitzlein has replied to Lars Trebing--
Seen in my account recent activity (?)
I live in Thailand/Bangkok now 28 years, travelling in every corner of this country, taking many thousands captures. I never had an experience like you had in this case in Germany in which some low minded youngsters hurt others just for a kick in their (non existent) brain. It really isn't my opinion to say that the Asians are generally more clever than the Western but in this case yes, they are – by a thousand times.
Sign-in to post a comment.