manganite Published on August 29, 2007
by manganite

manganite's blog

Browse posts
First thoughts about groups
Posted on September 22, 2007
2 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Limits
Posted on September 20, 2007
22 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Only a few hours left...
Posted on September 16, 2007
7 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Red - Green - Blue
Posted on September 2nd, 2007
2 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Ten weeks after...
28 comments (latest 9 months ago)
Nine weeks on ipernity...
Posted on August 22, 2007
17 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Honestly, I'm happy...
Posted on August 17, 2007
19 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Profit
Posted on August 14, 2007
19 comments (latest 2 years ago)
Where are the ads?
Posted on August 10, 2007
17 comments (latest 2 years ago)

Keyword tags

ipernity
flickr
activity
blog
photos
views
groups
leaving
pictures
members

Member tags

Christophe Ruelle
Christian Conti
Team ipernity
Lea d'ipernity
manganite
Gudrun
HarryBo73

More information

This post is public
All rights reserved
  1. 1 person added it to his favorites
  2. Read 869 times

Ten weeks after...

Wednesday August 29, 2007 at 08:29AM

...I started here posting my pictures the ipernity hype definitely has reached an end. Last week for the first time the number of contacts Lea ipernity has, has decreased instead of increased. And it's not just some  anyway unknown members, I lost some of my active contacts, cause they quit their account here. And the ones still here are more and more quiet.  Even some of the people who have announced on flickr very loudly that they will move to this place show not much activity.

And don't tell me about summer and vacation, they are still active on flickr.

Something is not working here. I'm not sure what it is, but I think it is connected with the poor possibilities to present your pictures here. No groups, only tiny icons of the pictures on the user homepage and the blog entries on top. I think that this leads to the stupid situation that my three line blog entry from last week got ten times more views than my last pictures on average in the last days.

Yes, I like the blog feature, I like the fact that you can upload documents, music or videos, but that's not why I am here. I'm here to share my pictures and that is working less and less, cause only a handful of active people is left. So I think, that I'm still uploading pictures here, is only because it doesn't cost me much effort to do so.

I hope, the situation will improve in future. The big thing will be groups I think, so staff has to do the job soon. It was announced almost two month ago and nothing had happened. And I think nothing is worse than announcing something and not doing it on time. But anyone, for some people it will be too late, they're gone and I don't think they will come back. Hopefully not much more will leave...

28 Comments / add your comment?

Zaphod says:
Mh, my fears are going in the same direction. But maybe it is not only a reaction of the people, The last entry in the ipernity-Team-Blog www.ipernity.com/blog/11832/ is from August 4th
Translation into italian, german and spanish was announced July 27th "very soon". This is a whole month ago ...
Is there still active developement? Is there still a "team ipernity"?
Leas space also is not updated for more than a month.
Are we riding on a ghost train, driven by an engine without drivers?
I hope not. I hope to hear of them soon ...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
Yes, I noticed that, too. And I think it's not only a job for the members to keep this page living, it's also the staff to show some activity motivating the members.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Christophe Ruellepro replies:
Hello Manganite & Zaphod,
we have not communicated a lot lately but we have improved dozen of things. We were waiting for major announcements to communicate. We will communicate soon about groups and other interesting features. stay tuned ;)
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
I will stay here and I'm looking forward what the new features will be.

I noticed the small changes, I can imagine that it is a lot of work to get rid off all the small errors and improving the performance. But from time to time one need some big improvement everyone noticed immediately.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Bigoode [Frozen account] replies:
of course we stay !
it's a very good community !
Shine on
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Zaphod replies:
Update: Lea is still alive ;). She uploaded some photos soon ...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Allure+Desire says:
i'm not sure if groups would really improve the situation. of course it's some rather substantial feature. anyway, the entire layout of the side is not really "photo friendly", the average photo quality is even worse than on flickr and there are definitely not enough active users.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
I think that groups could help to attract more active and good user for ipernity. There is really a lack of such people here. Most of the people here are satisfied to be active in there small community they know from flickr. They're not so much interested to look around searching the 'wow' pictures. So I can understand if people mainly interested in sharing their pictures are leaving.

And yes, the layout is really not photo friendly. That has to be improved, i think.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
pehei says:
Ich finde es bis jetzt ganz gemütlich auch wenn ich weniger views kriege.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink / translate )
manganite replies:
Gemütlich ja, aber auf dauer ist das, jedenfalls mir, zu langweilig...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink / translate )
pehei replies:
Ich wollte mich sowieso wieder mehr aufs Bilder machen konzentrieren. Flickr war mir oft schon zu viel. Das gemächliche Tempo hier finde ich ganz gut.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink / translate )
manganite replies:
Das ist dann wohl Geschmacksache...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink / translate )
Aref Nammari (goplayer) says:
I think maybe the problem is expectations. Ipernity is not flickr and I am glad for that, people who expect this to be flickr maybe should not have left flickr. There are a lot of people who have joined here and are still on flickr and it is very hard to manage the two efficiently at the same time.
I have contacted team ipernity about groups and I was told that they are working on it--there only three people and I presume that taking care of ipernity is not their only responsibility--and groups will be coming soon. In the mean time I have created a pseudo-group on my blog www.ipernity.com/blog/goplayer/19122 and anybody is welcome to participate--you don't need to join and you don't need an invitation with one of those animated, stupid and tasteless icons, just post. Others have done the same just look around. In all honesty I am glad that there are no groups here because I got sick and tired of all the tacky and superficial comments and invitations I was receiving while on flickr. Here I know that people who visit and comment on my pictures are sincere and do mean what they say not just filling a quota. I am sorry but if people want ipernity to be flickr maybe they shouldn't have left flickr. I personally like it here a lot and I don't miss flickr the least on the contrary I am glad I left and I am not looking for flickr somewhere else.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
pehei replies:
Yep. That's my opinion, too.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
Okay, they are working on it, that's fine. but they announced it 2 months ago to be ready in two weeks... And at that time, they were also only three people.

Never announce something you cannot hold, that's make people feel disappointed :(

Pseudo groups is a nice thing for some time. I made three pseudo groups in the beginning. Very good, but after some days they were lost somewhere in my my blog. Have you seen them or even noticed them? I don't think so...

I think pseudo groups is only a short life thing. you can play around with one group for let's say one week, than the it's time is over. Either it's lost in the blog of the user or it's so full of posts, that even with a broadband connection it takes too much time to load it.

It's simply not practicable on the long term. If we want to have groups, we need real groups, not pseudo groups.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Aref Nammari (goplayer) replies:
Is the problem groups? Is it not enough hits on your photos? To me quality is first not quantity. I could care less if a thousand people leave a thousand meaningless comments on my photos--I'd rather they say nothing than say some stupid insincere comment. What is important to me is the quality of interaction among people; the feedback--sincere and honest feedback--people provide so that I can improve; the inspiration I get from looking at others work and hopefully the inspiration I provide to others. What is important is the community in a true sense of the word--not the mass corporate crap that is flickr. If you like flickr so much why don't you just stick with it and put up with the crap they keep pulling? Many people like ipernity the way it is--I do. It could be better and the way to make it better is to provide constructive and concrete ideas not just bitching about what is wrong.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
The problem is the feeling boredom and inactivity produced by a stagnation or decline of members and contacts. The daily amount of noticeable good pictures and interesting new photostreams has drastically decreased, cause many of the best people are gone or no longer active.

Yes, the point is quality. Of pictures and of interactivity and both is not longer on the same level as it was weeks ago.

And yes, one has to think of how to improve this. But it must be allowed to think first and analyze what is wrong and what is the origin of problems. And for me the problem is, that the page in the current situation is not attractive enough to present pictures, cause they are not he center point of the page layout they get lost somewhere in the overall layout. And something like groups is missing, cause you need a place where people come together, sharing pictures of a certain topic and discussing about them. The blogging function is not enough.

And groups will lead to activity, giving the people the impression that something is going on, That this a page full of life.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
geor.g says:
I am open to possibilities but my gut reaction is that there is not the same amount of action here that is present on Flickr...
The addictive qualities of getting a hit and some recognition quickly is non existant.

I will continue to participate so that I can keep in touch with old friends.... but... they don't seem to have the same profile here either....... .... ... .. .
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
That's it.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
moritz™ says:
Thomas, as you are also very active on Flickr, I don't understand why you complain. In fact I don't appreciate this bitching about Ipernity. If you don't like it, leave. If I don't like it anymore I will leave. Sure, it could be better, more active and populated with more talented photographers. I will try to contribute as much as I can to make Ipernity more the place that I like. Therefore I submit bug reports and I actively participate in discussions. I write comments to other people's photos and I post my own stuff.

I wouldn't complain just because I don't get enough hits on my photos, because I can't expect the same rate of visitors here as on flickr. But I don't perceive this as a waste of time, because I like the more familiar atmosphere here.

Many good photographers aren't active in these photosharing sites anymore. Many of them I miss a lot (such as planetk and brodi). The remaining photographers are still good and to some degree inspiring (although many of them are just copying themselves). But I had to learn that these communities are only a very small part of the real world and that I have to look for alternatives outside the Web 2.0.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
No, I'm not complaining about ipernity itself or comparing it with flickr. For sure it has his own qualities and some advantages compared to flickr. What I'm talking about is, that this place has become boring, while it was very interesting, active and full of enthusiasm in the beginning. That's disappointing and I think many other people are disappointed, too. In the beginning people started pseudo groups, organized photo contests, were clicking around giving comments and so on. But many of them are no longer here or have stopped posting pictures.

Still I'm patient cause for sure one has to wait, I think, and posting pictures doesn't cost me much time, so why should I stop with it? And if I have time I look around at other peoples streams, searching for good pictures. But that's now much more difficult than it was in the beginning.

ABout the real world you're right. I also have the feeling I need some activity outside this communities. But of course that's not so easy...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Gudrun says:
The censorship on flickr made me really unhappy. A friend pointed this site out and I had a look see, made a profile and soon after that emptied all but three shots on my flickr account. I like it here, I do not compare this with flickr or anything else. I am not much for comparing, not matter what it is, I think it stifles innovation/thinking. But we need groups or something similar to get more interaction, make it easier to find new friends, friends with similar interests. A friendly discussion on what we would like is probably useful for the Ipernity government.
Those guys have done a great job and I am sure they are working on these issues as we speak.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Team ipernitypro says:
Some news of ipernity here : www.ipernity.com/blog/team/20717 ;-)
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
lichtundschattenpro says:
I like Ipernity and I don't feel bored. My communication runs quite well here but it could run much better.

One point is the lack of groups. I'm happy that we will have them soon.

In my opinion the main problem is, that you have no general view on your own and other comments like in Flickr. This prevents communication and discussion.

If Ipernity wants to become a real big and living community, it has to improve this point.
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
manganite replies:
But in principle the communication possibilities are much better here, and on your homepage your are much better informed what's going on in your network, you have the latest visitors, blogs, pictures, online users and so on.

So if there would be activity, you would notice it. But there is no activity. For hours there are often no new photos, sometimes a whole day no new blog entry, and the most depressing thing is, that the next morning always everything is as the evening before, while on flickr it takes time to check all the new activity...
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
HarryBo73 says:
Never announce something you cannot hold, that's make people feel disappointed


That is what I heard in one of my latest meetings, too.
If you say 3 days and it takes 2 weeks then we have to tell the people that it is not there 2 or 3 times. If you say 2 weeks, it is better and then you still can have it in 3 days ;-)

I can imagine that they needed to spent more work then intended to keep the system up and running after the swap from Flickr. That is usually work wish is not seen by the user. But more needed than any group feature, because if the system doesn't work you do not use it at all. But maybe this assumption is wrong and they already had a great infrastructure etc...

I just saw that groups will be launched in 2 weeks with basic features. That was a good decision because give us groups, additional features can be added later on.

But I have to confess that I miss new pictures here. After 3 days of absence, I just found 30 or 40 new pictures the last time from my over 100 contacts. But these are mostly from Germany or France, so this needs to be more international I think. But this was already stated and discussed before. Ok I could just go and look at everbodies photos but somehow I am stuck to my contacts, probably my fault

Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
melpomene says:
i'm coming in late to this blog but responding anyway. i agree that there has been less activity than when i first came here. i think the expectation of the groups brought people here then it didn't happen so they kind of dwindled off. i know i talked a couple of people into coming here from flickr and they don't even post here at all now. one was pretty popular over there so i suppose she didn't have any desire to move here.
i also agree that the blogs should NOT be at the top. that really bothers me and i delete mine after a week (with exceptions) just so they won't be on top. i actually love the design of the front page except for that. i don't like that only 5 albums will fit on the front page and you can't move them around. it pushed the one i wanted at the front all the way to the back and off the page when i put new albums up since last made goes to the front of the line.
i agree a bit about not liking groups over at flickr because i hated that i was forced to comment on other photos if i put one in a group. i also felt like the way to get more comments was to comment more on others. i just don't have the time with the zillion users over there. here i don't have so many to look through and i have time to comment. not that i comment to get comments but over there i rarely got comments. i felt like a needle in a haystack.

well, that's all of my useless opinion ; )
Posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )
Mahuya Nath says:
If you want to see some great blog click www.uploaded.tv where you can create a good blog also.
Posted 9 months ago. ( permalink )

Add your comment

Reply to this comment

Edit your comment

Please sign in to post a comment Sign in now?


rss Latest comments – Subscribe to the feed of comments related to this post.

 

Català | Čeština nové | 中文 | Deutsch | English | Español | Esperanto | Ελληνικά | Français | Galego | Italiano | Nederlands | Português | More...